Mascara Guide: 9 Top Picks For A Beautiful Look

Looking for the best mascara for your eyelashes? We’ve got you covered in this mascara guide. Every type of eye has different needs, and we’re here to ensure you’re armed with the right product to make yours look their best.

The search for the best mascara can be a time-consuming and daunting task. After all, not only is the world of cosmetics vast but what works for one woman’s eyelashes may not work for another. But here’s some good news: mascara applications can be educational besides being fun. For instance, you can see how different formulas affect your lashes and figure out the ideal curvature, length, and thickness you prefer. 

That’s why the team at True Beauty Spot has made it easy to browse and learn about (and ultimately buy) your favorite mascaras by creating a guide with the top 10 best mascara picks based on consumer reviews and experts’ recommendations. 

Our Top 9 Picks

  1. Best for those looking for instant volume–Pat McGrath labs dark star mascara
  2. Best for those who want to lengthen- Benefit they’re real! magnet extreme lengthening mascara
  3. Best for those who want a false-lash effect-Too Faced better than sex mascara.
  4. Best for lash conditioning -Lancôme le8 hypnôse mascara
  5. Best waterproof mascara – Benefit badgirl bang waterproof
  6. Best volumizing mascara – LashCraft Big Volume Mascara 
  7. Best mascara for eyelash primer – Kaja Wink Lash Trio Mascara
  8. Best non-smudging mascara – Nars Climax Mascara
  9. Best vegan mascara formula – Pacifica vegan collagen fluffy mascara

1. Pat McGrath labs dark star mascara

Bring out your eyes with the mascara from the brand created by one of the most influential makeup artists on the planet. Pat McGrath knows that a truly impressive mascara must have the perfect brush, which is why her mascara has a large, contoured brush that is ideal for building up layers of extra intensity. Perfect for when you need a bit of extra glamor for those special occasions.

Image Credit: Pacifica Beauty

Best: For instant volume

Rating: 8/10

  • Lash effect: Volumising
  • Vegan: No
  • Shades: Extreme black
  • Waterproof version available: No

Buy now on Sephora

2. Benefit they’re real! magnet extreme lengthening mascara

The benefit is always ahead of the game in the mascara department, and this new launch is no exception. The advanced brush has a magnetically charged core that draws up and out to the tips of lashes, making them appear longer. It also lifts and lengthens after just one stroke. And if you layer it, it builds volume with no dreaded clumping.

Image Credit: Benefit Cosmetics

Best: For the lengthening

Rating: 8/10

  • Lash effect: Lengthening and lifting
  • Vegan: No
  • Shades: Black
  • Waterproof version available: No

Buy now on Amazon

3. Too Faced better than sex mascara

This cult-favorite mascara has become the top-selling prestige mascara in the United States. This cheekily named formula has a reputation for creating drama that is still hard to beat. Although this mascara is all about dramatic lashes, it also works to clean and define individual lashes. The large, hourglass-shaped brush reaches all of your lashes, from root to tip. When applying, you notice that the volume and length are key, so you only need one coat of this mascara.

Image Credit: Too Faced

BEST: For false-lash effect

RATINGS: 9/10

  • Lash effect: Lengthening and curling
  • Vegan: Yes
  • Shades: Black
  • Waterproof version available: No

Buy now on Amazon.

4. Lancôme le8 hypnôse mascara

This new mascara from Lancôme is a game-changer for those with dry, brittle lashes. The lash conditioning serum and hypnôse wand work together to create a natural, full-bodied effect that is easier to remove than other mascaras on the market. The hourglass brush leaves your lashes looking thick and beautiful, while the rectangular and curved design of the tube is unique and eye-catching. Whether you’re looking for a way to add volume or length to your lashes, this mascara is worth checking out!

Image Credit: Lancome

Best: Lash conditioning

Rating: 9/10

  • Lash effect: Natural but full-bodied
  • Vegan: No
  • Shades: Black
  • Waterproof version available: No 

Buy now on Amazon

5. Benefit badgirl bang waterproof

The waterproof version of benefit’s badgirl bang mascara is now available, and it’s a summer must-have. The ultralight formula adds buildable, natural-looking volume with its streamlined wand without weighing down your flutter. You can rely on it to get you through the warmer months or that beach holiday you’ve planned.

Image Credit: Beauty Cosmetics

Best: Waterproof mascara

Rating: 8/10

  • Lash effect: Volumising
  • Vegan: No
  • Shades: One
  • Waterproof version available: Not applicable 

Buy now on Amazon

6. Lashcraft Big Volume Mascara

This mascara is a great option for anyone looking for a high-quality volumizing mascara that will make their lashes look thick and bold. Its formula includes plumping polymers that give your lashes volume, and the wand coats each lash evenly. This mascara is also smudge-proof and waterproof, making it a great option for those with watery eyes.

Image Credit: Saphora

Best: Volume

Rating: 8/10

  • Lash effect: Bolder-looking
  • Vegan: Yes
  • Shades: One 
  • Waterproof version available: Yes

Buy now on Amazon

7. Kaja Wink Lash Trio Mascara

This mascara is truly everything you could need in one convenient package. It features a lash primer, brow serum, lengthening mascara, and volumizing formula in one easy-to-use tube. The precision spoolie is perfect for getting those long, luscious lashes, while the fluffy brush provides just the right amount of volume. Truly, this is what you need.

Image Credit: Kaja Beauty

Best: Volumizing mascara

Rating: 9/10

  • Lash effect: Volumising
  • Vegan: No
  • Shades: One
  • Waterproof version available: No

Buy now on Amazon.

8. Nars Climax Mascara

This mascara is my go-to for my everyday look. The full wand has flexible bristles that coat every lash for natural lift and curl without clumps. You can wear it through an entire day of work (or an entire evening out), and I rarely end up with flakes or smudges under my eyes. It is magic.

Image Credit: Nars Cosmetics

Best: For intense drama

Rating: 8/10

  • Lash effect: Volumising
  • Vegan: No
  • Shades: Black, Extreme black
  • Waterproof version available: No

Buy now on Amazon

9. Pacifica vegan collagen fluffy mascara

One of the most popular items in the collection is the volume and lengthening mascara, which uses tiny plant fibers to adhere to lashes for a more potent effect. The big, hourglass brush makes it easy to layer on for a bolder look with a glossy finish, and the big glass tube with the pretty pastel gradient packaging adds to the luxe feel. Another standout product is the eyeshadow palette, which contains 12 beautiful shades that you can use to create countless looks. The pigmented eyeshadow blends effortlessly, making it a dream to work with.

Image Credit: Pacifica Beauty

Best: Vegan formula

Rating: 8.5/10

  • Lash effect: Natural
  • Vegan: Yes
  • Shades: Black
  • Waterproof version available: No

Buy now on Amazon.

How to get the most out of your mascara

Most of us don’t follow the recommended two to four-month timeframe to replace our mascara. We hang on to tubes beyond their expiration date to eke out every drop. If this sounds like you, then consider these tips to help extend the life of your mascara:

If your mascara gets dry and clumpy, add a few drops of saline solution (used for contact lenses) to re-wet it. Just be sure not to remove any dried mascara from the wand before adding the saline solution, as this can cause bacteria to grow. Another trick is to place your mascara in the refrigerator for about 15 minutes before using it. This will help firm up the consistency and make it easier to apply. Finally, if you want your lashes to have full-on drama, follow this guide and apply a primer beforehand, which helps get your mascara working.

Our Best Mascara

According to our mascara guide, the best buy award goes to Lancôme lash idôle mascara because it effortlessly creates a natural-looking volume that is ideally suited for daily wear and is easily buildable for an even bolder look. Try Maybelline lash sensational sky-high mascara for a high street option.

Verdict

There are a lot of great mascaras on the market, but finding the right one for you can be a bit of a trial-and-error process. Hopefully, this guide has given you insights into what to look for in a mascara and some of the best available ones

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Translate »